Synthesis

Synthesis of the inconsistency of the Lorentz force law

Links in the document

Mathematical cause of the existence of the remaining resultant internal Lorentz force

Proof of the remaining resultant Lorentz force internal to a triangular coil

Lorentz torque experiment

I need help

Complete study

Paradoxes and solutions about Lorentz force law

Mathematical cause of the existence of the remaining resultant internal Lorentz force

Mathematical cause of the existence of the remaining resultant internal Lorentz force
19 avril 2012

I have given a rigorous proof of the existence of a remaining resultant Lorentz force internal to a triangular coil and a numerical computation that confirms this proof:

Proof of the remaining resultant Lorentz force internal to a triangular coil
https://docs.google.com/open?id=0B3YDEaOyRUwca0lsRlVfSXpYbWM

http://pengkuanem.blogspot.com/2012/04/analyze-of-lorentz-forces-internal-to.html

Why the Lorentz force law cannot respect the third Newton’s law? What is the mathematical cause that leads to this inconsistency? Let us examine the effect of the characteristic perpendicularity of the Lorentz force with the current. Take a triangle with height h and base a+b (see the Figure 1). 

Documents Links

Proof of the remaining resultant Lorentz force internal to a triangular coil

PengKuan 彭宽, titang78@gmail.com

12 April 2012

The Lorentz force respects the third Newton's law. Is the Lorentz force internal to a coil consistent with the third Newton's law ? Let us analyze the triangular coil ABC in the Figure 1; the current is I . Each side feels a Lorentz force from the magnetic field of the coil itself. The resultant force of all the Lorentz forces on the 3 sides is the double integrated F.

I have done a numerical computation for a triangular coil with base length of 1 and height of 10. The calculated force is dimensionless and the value of the overall resultant force is (see the Figure 2):

S= 35.21 e_y

This force is not 0, violating the third Newton's law. In general, this value suffices to prove that the Lorentz force law is flawed, because only one counter example is sufficient to topple a general law. However, to exclude any doubt about the accuracy of this numerical calculation, I have done a rigorous analytical proof, which gives the expression of the dimensionless resultant force for a isosceles triangular coil, F_res  .

Thus, the analytical method proves without a doubt that the Lorentz force law is flawed. The mathematical derivation of the proof is given in the Mathematical Proof (see pdf link or below).

I need help

 I need help

PengKuan, titang78@gmail.com

15 April 2012

No, I do not need money.

The help I need is you, young and enthusiastic physicists. I need your hand, your faith in physics, your belief in the progress of physics. I need some experiments to be done, some ground-breaking ones.

The standard theory of electromagnetism with more than 150 years has proven its great value. However, its merit must not impede the improvement of our understanding of the electromagnetic phenomena.

I have found some new knowledge on electromagnetism. The big problem is that this finding contradicts the standard theory, and the wall I encountered in the physical community is harder than the Great Wall of China. Actually, the mainstream physicists believe in the Maxwell system like a religion, and all questioning of it is rejected without consideration.

This immediate refusal constitutes the greatest obstacle of progress. History has many lessons for us. The refusal of reconsideration of the geocentrism has prevented the heliocentrism to be known. So, never refuse to think that our present knowledge is wrong, no matter how exact it was until now. If we have an alternative theory, why not see if it were right? Do not blind our eyes by believing that the last theory is the ultimate one. Horizon can never be reached, but by trying to approach it, we will find new horizon.

The best way to decide which horse is the fastest is to make them contest. The best way to decide which theory is best is to do experiment. You, our generation's physicists who may complain not to live in a glorious epoch, who dream to make great discovery, do the experiment I propose. It confronts the predictions of the Lorentz force law and that of the differential Ampere's force law. The outcome of experiment is the only judge.

Galileo discovered acceleration by experiment and proved that Aristotle was wrong. Dare to be the Galileo of today by uncovering hidden nature of magnetic force and proving that Lorentz was wrong.

Do not fear failure, failure is an aphrodisiac of sciences that gives birth to beautiful children. Do not fear to appear ridiculous. Nothing is more ridiculous than to assert that train will shorten when moving fast. Ridiculousness to the contemporary, to the standard theory, is a characteristic of all great scientists and great ideas.

Make the true force reveal! It will be "one small step for a man, one giant leap for mankind"!

It will not be my step, but yours. So, let's go.